The Quiet Crisis Facing American Churches


Hello Reader ,

Few church decisions carry as much emotion as deciding what to do when a congregation can no longer sustain its building or current structure.

In our newest Coffee & Counsel, we explore an important truth: a church's next chapter may take more than one form.

Sharing space, relocating, merging, or winding down an organization can all raise questions about leadership authority, property, obligations, and ministry continuity.

One question I hope every church board will consider is:

“If our circumstances changed significantly, would we know what our governing documents require?”Watch the conversation here:
​

If a merger is one option your church is exploring, our Guide to Church Mergers may be a helpful place to begin.

You're Invited! December Legal Briefing: Church Staffing Done Right

Are you confident your church is properly classifying workers, structuring compensation, and making informed decisions about employee benefits?

Just because someone receives a 1099 doesn't automatically mean they're an independent contractor. And when it comes to paying church staff, even well-intentioned decisions can create legal and financial risks if the applicable requirements aren't understood.

That's why I'm excited to partner with Liz Lindamood of HR Ministry Solutions for our upcoming Legal Briefing!

Church Staffing Done Right: A Legal Guide to Worker Classification, Compensation & Benefits

📅 Tuesday, December 8, 2026

⏰ 12:00 PM ET

💻 Online

During this special session, we'll discuss:

  • Employees vs. Independent Contractors: How to determine the appropriate classification for church workers.
  • Compensation: Important considerations when structuring pay and understanding wage requirements.
  • Employee Benefits: What churches should consider when offering benefits and managing employer responsibilities.
  • Common Staffing Mistakes: Potential legal and HR pitfalls that could put your ministry at risk.

Plus, we'll wrap up with a 15-minute live Q&A with Liz and Erika, giving you the opportunity to ask your church staffing questions!

Why Attend Just One Legal Briefing When You Can Access Them All?

Church staffing is just one of the many legal and compliance issues ministry leaders navigate throughout the year.

That's why we created Faithful Foundations, a membership designed to equip churches with ongoing legal education and practical resources to help protect their ministries.

And here's one of the biggest benefits:

ALL of our Legal Briefings are included in your Faithful Foundations Membership!

Instead of purchasing individual briefings throughout the year, you can join Faithful Foundations and receive access to every Legal Briefing as part of your membership.

You'll also gain access to additional resources designed specifically for church leaders, with live Q&A opportunities available through our All Access Membership.

Already a Faithful Foundations Member? You're automatically registered for the December briefing! Check your inbox for your registration confirmation from Thinkific.

Whether you purchase access to this individual briefing or become a member, we hope you'll join us on December 8.

Let's continue building stronger, legally sound foundations for our ministries.

Blessings!

This email is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, accounting, or tax advice, nor does it create an attorney-client relationship. The information provided here was based on certain federal and/or state statutes and does not encompass all applicable requirements or other regulations that may exist, such as local ordinances or case law.

Thanks for reading! If you loved it, tell your friends to subscribe. To change your email or preferences manage your profile. If you didn’t enjoy the email you can unsubscribe here.

6925 Oakland Mills Rd Box 171, Columbia, MD 21045

The Church Attorney Consulting Services, LLC

As The Church Attorney®, denominations and churches select my proprietary Legal Audit System to position themselves to operate in integrity, avoid IRS audits, and position themselves for growth. Every church leader should take advantage of my free Church Law podcast and subscribe to my free newsletter.

Read more from The Church Attorney Consulting Services, LLC

Hello Reader , When you think about Black Friday, what comes to mind? Maybe it's finding a great deal on something you've had your eye on, getting a head start on Christmas shopping, or finally making that purchase you've been putting off. But this year, I want to encourage you to think about Black Friday a little differently. What if one of the most valuable investments you make this season isn't something you buy for yourself, but something you do for your church? As we approach 2027, there...

Hello Reader , A church building holds memories: baptisms, weddings, funerals, prayers, and generations of service. So when church leaders question whether they can continue in their current space, the conversation is rarely just about finances or real estate. The reality is difficult: the building that helped a church grow 30 years ago may now be limiting its growth. So how can a church manage these risks? Some churches explore sharing a building. Others relocate, merge, or consider a...

Hello Reader , Your church's people make ministry possible. But the decisions behind the scenes—who is an employee, how people are paid, and which benefits are offered—can create obligations that aren't always obvious. Consider a musician who serves every weekend, an administrator paid a flat amount each month, or a ministry worker described as a “contractor.” Those labels and arrangements may seem straightforward, but the legal analysis can be more complicated. That's why The Church...